|
I'm beating the other blogs to this.
The ACLU finally filed an amicus brief on behalf of the FLDS children. Read it here. Good stuff.
Response to state's petition is here.
I'm expecting an opinion from SCOT this afternoon. Tomorrow morning at the latest. I would hate to be a SCOT clerk this week.
Amicus brief from some stereotypical social worker type woman.
WOOOT!!! Favorable ruling! Orders are here. This isn't a ruling, I don't think, on the general issue, but a ruling on the petition for emergency relief (i.e. for the state not to have to follow the 3rd court of appeals' order). That means that for now, at least, a few of the kids, at least, are getting to go home.
MARS ON A TRICYCLE. As I'm understanding it, the court ruled 6-3 that CPS didn't satisfy the legal requirements for removing any of the children, and the trial court abused its discretion in giving the state guardianship. The three dissenting members of the court agree with the majority that the state didn't satisfy legal requirements for removing anyone except the prepubescent girls, although they think the state presented adequate evidence for the removal of adolescent girls.
In other words, it looks like a unanimous ruling that the trial court abused its discretion in the removal of the vast majority of the kids.
Upon further reading, it does look like a full endorsement of the 3rd court of appeals' decision.
|